I’ve been following the blogs of some KaosPilots, particularly those that are on OutPosts overseas (that tends to be the main reason for their blogging). Quite honestly, I haven’t seen much in the way of cultural awareness – or even an attempt to understand and appreciate their host societies.
Most of the OutPost blogs tend to feature parties and gatherings – photos after photos of blonde blue-eyed Scandinavians drinking the night away while they party in an exotic country. There’s very little in the way of actually examining the culture, exploring their location, or even the work they’re doing. The work in their OutPosts are usually relegated to one or two posts – “this is our project, tada!”. Otherwise? Party party party.
The team in Mumbai right now are tasked with answering questions about India, sent in by the KP board members. One student is taking in questions from the Web – and, quite frankly, his response to the latest two questions shows a deep level of ignorance:
Implying that the West has made mistakes is apparently biased!
Cellphones and Internet in India is rare, people marry young, and Indians must be liberal with porn because men like to share porn on phones!
Complete headdesk-worthy. (Read my comments on the above posts for my responses.)
Two KaosPilots blogs that I find to be very thoughtful and reflective about the educational processes are Henrique’s and Zulma’s (Zulma’s website also rocks hardcore). Henrique is in China and his blog has plenty of thoughtful and interesting entries on China and Chinese culture, including the conflicts with Tibet. He really shows his effort at understanding his host country. Zulma’s is more personal, but she talks a lot about her projects, and the processes she goes through in completing them. She also talks about her budding life in Denmark – including a new baby! (aww).
It’s really interesting that the two blogs I featured above are both from international students – Henrique is from Brazil and I believe Zulma is from Colombia. They have had to face the challenges of being outsiders, of being foreigners, from Day One – while most of their classmates would have been right at home in similar cultures. Now these students are overseas too, sent by their outposts – and they haven’t quite picked up the skills of cultural awareness, of just being curious about where they are. They’ve instead become insular, clinging on to old patterns while dismissing their host culture’s patterns as just oddities.
I’m rather glad that the KaosPilots Netherlands have announced that they’re received expressions of interest from all over – Russia, India, Nepal, a few other places (including multi-country me). This would lead to a much richer pool of applicants, and hopefully this batch would be much more culturally aware than the others. I’ve checked out the Facebook group for the latest Aarhus school, Team 15, and there doesn’t seem to be any indication of non-Europeans in their team (and apparently Macs are MANDATORY! What?!).
It does make me wonder, though – why are the students of the “best school for the world” seemingly unaware of the world they’re in?
May 19, 2008 at 5:13 pm
Really dont agree in the things you are writing.. Anyway.. Good luck to you with the Amsterdam application..
(in team 15, there are people from south korea and costa rica, so far)
May 19, 2008 at 5:14 pm
Really dont agree in the things you are writing.. Anyway.. Good luck to you with the Amsterdam application..
(in team 15, there are people from south korea, costa rica and Iceland, so far)
May 19, 2008 at 5:27 pm
In which parts don’t you agree? Jen’s knowledge of India was rather lacking, and many of the other KP blogs are heavy on the “here’s our party!” and lacking on other substance.
I tried looking for KP photos on Flickr some months ago, but for some reason, out of the thousands of photos uploaded, very very few (like maybe 5 at the most) were of any ACTION. The vast majority were of parties, hanging around, lounging.
Where’s the spirit that inspired the Tibetan football team, the rebuilding of the Sarajevo/Croatia youth club, the Kenyan women’s empowerment movement? What’s happening this year? Where’s the substance?
May 20, 2008 at 4:56 pm
The intention of my blog is to express what I feel when I feel it. As said in the about section:
This is for selfdevelopment purposes so i can write pretty much whatever I want! And so i will…
Have a beautiful day!
May 20, 2008 at 5:34 pm
“If its on flickR its true” and “if one said it, judge them all”.
I really do think the world is a little bit more complex than that.
Cheers
May 20, 2008 at 8:59 pm
Jens: sure, you can say what you feel, but when answering questions about different cultures, it would be well advised to be better informed about the culture you’re being asked about. Even though this blog is personal too, I can’t just say “oh all Scandinavians are superficial” or whatever, because it’s not informed nor educated. I would think as an Outpost member you would be responsible for being an ambassador of India to the KaosPilots and of the KaosPilots to India, so knowledge and understanding is essential.
Pelle: Neither of your statements are actually true of my blog entry. What I am commenting on is the lack of displayed substance (your sentence about Flickr makes it sound like there’s no such thing as parties in the Kaospilots…?) and that there really isn’t much of the past few years that has deviated from that.
I know that entrepreneurial, world-changing spirit is THERE, else I wouldn’t apply for it. But where is it? Why is it not written up more often? Why is my only source for this information the KaosPilots official sites? The only thing I could think of that was close to this is the recent Pangea Day in Mumbai, which was great. Where’s there rest of it? Where’s all the change?
May 20, 2008 at 9:12 pm
[...] danish, debate, musings, substance, translation help, value | Seems that my last post hit quite a nerve – Jens made his blog protected and I’ve suddenly got more KPs coming out of the woodwork. My [...]
May 20, 2008 at 9:26 pm
Ouch, heh.
May 21, 2008 at 10:00 am
hey tiara..this looks like an interesting post. on the way to work soon, will read this again, but here’s a sudden brainfart i wanted to record: when you say culture, do you refer to traditional or contemporary culture? and aren’t people more generally inclined to take photographs in a party?
May 21, 2008 at 10:12 am
Lainie: heya
By culture I mean whatever’s happening now – traditional or current. In many places the two cross together and there are very interesting juxtapositions.
Mark pointed out the party+camera thing too
I figured, though, that if the main purpose of your trip was to work on projects, you’d document it a lot more?